India's new private universities: how much of a game changer?

The Economist has an upbeat story  about India's new crop of private universities. But its title - India's pricey universities want to take on the Ivy League- suggests it is getting carried away. The new private universities could, at bestm become India's Ivy League but that's hardly the same as taking on America's.

The new universities- Ashoka, Shiv Nadar, Krea, Jindal, Ahmedabad, to name a few- are funded by businessmen. The Economist writes:

The new crop of private universities set themselves apart in several ways. From the beginning they have sought to excel in research, not just in teaching. Many emphasise humanities and social sciences, says Eldho Mathews, an education researcher in Kerala—which in other Indian institutions are often considered secondary to science-based subjects and also to training for the professions.

Well, the new private universities have distinguished themselves from the general run of public universities. However, other than Ashoka, which has an outstanding undergraduate programme, none remotely approaches the Ivy League in quality. Perhaps they do not even match the rigour and class of the best IITs and IIMs. They have a long way to go.

The Economist sees the new universities as having to deal with sensitivity to research on controversial issues:

A big worry is the Indian government’s intolerance for research or opinion that it finds irksome. Self-censorship is rife in the social sciences in particular, says one academic. Publishing an inconvenient finding can easily “blow up in your face”. Sensitive topics include religious freedom and the state of India’s democracy.

It's not clear that is the biggest problem. One problem certainly is attracting quality faculty. Not many have established a tenure system, whereby security is tenure is assured after a probationary period of the first few years. Nor is the faculty pay particularly attractive except in a few places. The IITs and the IIMs offer not just pay but quality accommodation, job security and substantial funds for research and travel. The new private universities do not uniformly measure up on these counts. The new universities also tend to have a centralised model of leadership, more akin to that of ordinary Indian universities than the IIT and the IIMs.

That the new universities are backed by businessmen does not  a blank cheque. The institutions are expected to meet a substantial portion of their funding requirements through fees and executive training. After the initial bout of funding, the business backers are often reluctant to provide substantial support. The formula for IITs and IIMs has proved unbeatable: 100 acres or so of land, Rs 150 to 200 crore for initial capital expenditure and recurring revenue grants of upwards of Rs 100 crore - for at least ten years.

The new universities will be preferred to the typical Indian college. But Ivy League is miles away.