Monday, November 16, 2026

FII flows into India: how important was blue wave?

 FIIs have returned to India with a bang. Almost $9 bn dollar has flowed into the Indian equity markets until November 13.

Many ascribe this to the 'blue wave' in the US in the elections to Congress on November 3. They say that investors are switching out of AI stocks after the Democrats' win as they believe the Democrats will rein in things that conduce to AI investment such as data centres.

I am not sure. The FII inflows into India had resumed in the second week of October itself. Scepticism about AI stock valuations and a correction had started last summer with major cloud and AI hyperscalers  falling 10 per cent in October. If investors had perceived Indian equities as the alternative, we would have seen large purchases of Indian stocks even earlier.

My own view is that confidence in a stable rupee is the more important factor. After the RBI curbs on forex demand in October, the rupee appreciated from  just below 97 to the dollar to around 94. At that point, FIIs came to believe that they could expect better dollar returns from the Indian market than before and decided to plunge into Indian equities again.

The RBI's defence of the rupee- basically that is what it is even though the RBI calls it a reaction to excessive speculation- seems to have produced results for now.

More in my BS column, The real good news.

 The real good news

It is the stable rupee, not the blue wave in the US

Indians- and others in the United States (US) and elsewhere- jubilant over the blue wave that swept the Democrats to power in the US Congress, got a cold reality check last week. US President Donald Trump elevated one of his aides, Stephen Miller, as White House chief of staff.

Mr Miller has been characterised as an anti-immigration hawk. He is better characterised as an economic nationalist and a passionate advocate of Mr Trump’s “America First” programme. Absolutely central to that programme is the use of tariffs to advance America’s interests.

Mr Miller is not the principal exponent of tariffs in the Trump administration. Nevertheless, his elevation is important in that it signals that there will be no retreat from Mr Trump’s ideological agenda. That means, among other things, that the world cannot expect the slightest relief with respect to tariffs. India must brace itself for more tough negotiations on the long-pending India-US trade deal. There will be no respite with respect to H1-B visas either.

The seriously good news for India is not the blue wave but the turnaround on the home front of a sort that few had expected. The rupee has appreciated consequent to the forex measures the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) announced last month. In October, it looked as though the rupee would slide below 97 to the dollar in what looked like a free fall. Instead, the rupee has appreciated to above 94.  

The RBI’s measures, which curbed the demand for dollars, are not the only reason for the appreciation of the rupee. Global factors have contributed. Investors are retreating from artificial-intelligence (AI) stocks. Yields on US Treasuries have eased. The price of crude oil has dropped to below $100 per barrel.

But the RBI’s measures are undoubtedly an important factor. By containing expectations about rupee depreciation, they appear to have revived foreign institutional investors’ (FIIs’) appetite for Indian stocks. Market pundits who claimed that India had fallen off the radar of foreign investors may well end up looking foolish.

The RBI’s position is that it is not out to defend any particular level of the rupee. Its measures in October were only about preventing “excessive” speculation. “Excessive” speculation is hard to define or determine. The RBI governor said that one-third of all foreign-exchange derivative trades were being cancelled or closed out on the same day they were initiated. He also pointed to one-sided bets against the rupee. It’s not clear why either should be regarded as “excessive”. Both transactions could merely reflect expectations that the rupee is likely to depreciate.

Speculation is unhealthy when it threatens to destabilise the system, say, when large bets are taken with little capital to support them, or when groups of participants are colluding to push the exchange rate in a particular direction. A sudden decline in the exchange rate is also unhealthy when it points to market dysfunction, for example, when small transactions result in large movements in the exchange rate.  

There was no evidence of any of these, yet the RBI thought it necessary to intervene in the forex market. It did so for another compelling reason: Too steep a fall in the exchange rate in a short period can be self-reinforcing and result in overshooting.

When the rupee depreciates by a large percentage over a certain period, investors such as FIIs become jittery. They see that depreciation is eroding their dollar returns. They head for the exit, which causes the rupee to depreciate even further. By intervening to stabilise the rupee, the RBI can contain a perceived currency risk. That improves the prospects of FIIs entering the market instead of exiting, thereby causing the rupee to appreciate.

That is exactly what seems to have happened after the RBI announced its curbs on dollar demand in October. FII flows were hugely negative in April, May and June in the current  financial year. They turned positive in July and August (apparently because of primary-market investment while selling in secondary markets continued). FII flows turned negative again in September and October.

The RBI announced its curbs on the demand for dollars on October 10. By October 16, the rupee had appreciated to 94.96 to the dollar from its level of 96.82 on October 8. At that point, FIIs turned net buyers and they remained net buyers for 14 sessions thereafter up to November 6. In the first six days of November, FII inflows into equities were greater than the outflows in each of the months of September and October.   

When the RBI announced its measures, critics said the curbs could not be sustained for long.  When the forex curbs are removed, the rupee will be under pressure if oil prices rise above $100. They are right but it’s also true that sentiment is a big factor in the markets. Intervention of the sort the RBI has undertaken helps turn around sentiment in many ways.

First, speculators betting against the rupee end up suffering losses when curbs on dollar demand cause the rupee to appreciate. Such losses impair their capacity to bet against the rupee once normalcy is restored. Secondly, the RBI has sent out a signal that one-way bets can be costly. Market participants will think twice before they bet against the rupee after the curbs are removed.

Thirdly, market expectations of a steep depreciation in the rupee become less entrenched. This encourages FIIs to invest in Indian equities. FII inflows, in turn, contribute to further appreciation of the rupee. That is how the vicious spiral of rupee depreciation in the previous months now promises to turn virtuous.

When the RBI announced its forex measures in October, critics refused to buy its position that it was not defending any particular value of the rupee.  They said the RBI was doing precisely that. The talk in the market and in the media was that an exchange rate of ~97 to the dollar was a line in the sand for the RBI.  

Let us say the market thinks the rupee should fall to 100 in three months. The RBI thinks that should happen in one year and intervenes to prevent a sharp fall towards 100. Its intervention results in the rupee stabilising  at 98. Is that a defence of the rupee or preventing unhealthy speculation? Let the pundits and market experts quibble. For now, the success of the RBI’s measures is cause for celebration.

 

 

 


Thursday, October 29, 2026

How does Tata Sons process investment proposals?

I was taken aback by this report in today's TOI:

Noel Tata, chairman of Tata Trusts, the controlling shareholder of Tata Sons, has called for greater scrutiny of large investments by the holdings company, requiring  management to present detailed business cases, setting out the rationale, expected financial returns and risks of capita commitments before directors sign off on them, said people familiar with the matter. 

Is this true? Were the proposals approved by the board last June without the required details being presented? 

Tata Sons Chairman N Chandrasekaran or some senior official of the Tata group needs to clarify. 


 

SIR, without love: are lack of additions the problem, not exclusions?

There is an outcry over the number of people whose names have been deleted from the electoral rolls. 

The number is said to be 13 crore across the country or about 12 per cent of the eligible voters. For the opposition, this has become a huge issue.

So I was surprised by the contents of an article by Jean Dreze in ET. Dreze is a liberal and no friend of the government.

Dreze argues that  the deletions are not the issue. The deletions happen  because of deaths, movement from one place to another, double counting etc. 

He  contends that the ground-level reports suggest that the majority of deletions are LEGITIMATE.

But then the numbers on the voter list fall short of the adult population by 15 per cent. How do we explain this? 

Dreze says that the problem is not exclusion but non-inclusion. About 10 per cent of the eligible voters had been left out in the  past. And the latest SIR exercise does little to remedy the non-inclusion.

By focusing on exclusion and not on inclusion, the EC has failed to ensure that all eligible  voters get a chance to exercise their franchise. 

The EC is seeking to remedy this. It has announced a Special Summary Revision where the intent is to include those who do not find a place in the rolls.

Dreze's argument, if true, would take the sting out of the opposition claim that the EC has deliberately set out to disenfranchise a large chunk of the electorate by deleting their names- that is, if deletions are not the problem in the first place.

The problem is that in some places- Delhi and Maharashtra, for instance- the deletions are far too numerous. And then in West Bengal, almost in 90 per cent of the appeals that have been  processed so far, the exclusions have been rejected. The proceedings in the honourable Supreme Court are on. We need to see what view the SC takes on the exclusions. 

Sunday, September 27, 2026

India's oil import basket today is priced at $114-115!

 The media seems to have not given adequate attention to an important figure cited by CEA V Anantha Nageswaran. India's basket of imported crude is now priced at $114-115. The  CEA mentioned this figure at an SBI Conclave last week. He said this amounted to a rise of over 30 per cent from the price of $85-90 in June-July. 

The price of Brent crude is today $104. But that is the price of futures. The figure mentioned by the CEA probably takes into current spot prices which are ruling much higher.

India's basket of crude oil cost $71 in FY 26. So what we have now is a 61 per cent rise over the FY 26 price. It explains why the rupee is edging towards Rs 96 per dollar despite the inflows of  $143 bn through the forex swap route.

The interesting thing is gdp growth remains strong despite the huge increase in oil price we are facing- growth is projected at around 7 per cent by most estimates.

Wednesday, September 23, 2026

Trump will receive Xi at the airport in a first

President Trump will receive President Xi of China at Andrews Air Force base, breaking with six decades of protocol. In May, when Trump visited China, Xi did not travel to Beijing airport.

The  FT believes that Trump may have caged the China hawks in his cabinet.

Trump started off his term with hawkish measures, include stiff tariffs on China that went up to 140 per cent. China retaliated with tariffs and then used its trump card- it slowed down exports of critical minerals to the US. 

That brought about an agreement on scaled down tariffs between the two countries and a revival of critical mineral exports.

But why would Trump think it necessary to go to the airport to receive Xi? That is not clear from the FT story. Is is anything more than wanting to preserve the Busan agreement?


IIT Bombay suicide: crime and punishment

The debates on TV and in other places are along predictable lines and pretty sterile.

If a professor finds a student is cheating, is that a crime?

Is it right to invoke the SC/ST act just because an SC student is involved?

How can IITs maintain their standards if they cannot enforce academic integrity?

We need to be clear that the issue is not cheating but how an institution responds to it.

Cheating in exams clearly is not on- it is unfair to those who  are not cheating. So the issue is not whether the professor was right in intervening when he found somebody was using his mobile (assuming for the moment that is what happened, since the matter is under investigation). The issue is: How do you respond to acts of cheating? 

At IITs and IIMs in general, faculty tend to be behave as though copying or plagiarism are the ultimate crime worthy of capital punishment.

Sorry, no. There are much bigger sins in this world than cheating in exams. And the answer to cheating is not to act in ways that would ruin a student's career or life. Some deterrence is required. If it is a major exam (such as the end term), perhaps an F grade may be  appropriate. For a 10-mark in-term quiz, you may mark down the student's grade by one or two notches.

But that's not how the system responds. Students are often told to repeat a semester. They may face suspension for a year (which, it is alleged, was the threat made to the IIT Bombay student). Or you may face expulsion from the Institute), which could means years of wasted time and money and utter devastation.

At IIMA, where I taught for more than two decades, I was taken aback at the sheer fury that faculty displayed when instances of cheating came to light. Many would howl for the severest punishment to be meted out. In one pathetic case, the mother of the student facing expulsion fell at the feet of the Programme Chair and begged forgiveness- she was asked to leave the room and the Institute went ahead with the punishment.

I found it difficult to digest faculty claims of uncompromising adherence to principle. The same concern for principle was notably absent where those above were involved, say, the director or even senior colleagues. Student  cheating was a petty transgression compared to the colossal violations perpetrated by those in positions of authority. Faculty's attitude towards these violations was one of benign indifference. 

So don't tell me about academic integrity. Academic integrity applies not just to students but to everybody in the system. It is just one aspect of institutional integrity. Show your adherence to scruple with respect to all violations of norms, not just violations on the part of students. Otherwise, what you are doing is nothing more than cheap bullying and abuse of power.

This morning, I saw a note by S H Patil, a distinguished professor of Physics at IIT Bombay, who taught me when I was a student there. He says he carried out an experiment with examinations. He would give open book exams with no time limit- you could take ten minutes or ten hours to finish them. At the end of the day, the answer sheets were to be dropped off at his office. He would tell students he expected them to observe norms of fair play. His experiment worked wonderfully except in a couple of cases. In those cases, he simply spoke to the students and reminded them of basic principles.

That is the way to go. Repose trust in students, try to develop a peer culture  of enforcement and overlook or respond mildly to the occasional transgression. Cheating in exams is not such a big crime that one has to pay for it with one's life. 

Post-script: IIT B has set up a ten member committee, including student representatives, to look into the incident. The press report says the Institute has shared the composition of the committee with the Ministry and awaits its approval. Clearly, the government has waved the danda at the Institute. The government understands that an internal committee appointed by the director would have little credibility. 


Friday, September 11, 2026

Why boards fail at succession planning

The heads of Tata Sons and HDFC Bank are due to depart soon. The boards are looking for a successor. Good succession planning means a tentative list of successors should be available long before an incumbent's departure.

Succession planning is poor because CEOs don't want to leave. And boards don't have it in them to challenge the incumbent on this matter, as on any other matter.

We will get sound succession planning when boards cease to be dysfunctional. That requires an overhaul of how board directors are selected in the first place.

More in my column, Why boards fail at succession planning.

FINGER ON THE PULSE
T T RAM MOHAN

Why boards fail at succession planning

You have done your job, we are grateful, but we feel the time has come for you to make way for somebody else. 

If only boards of directors had it in them to deliver the simple message to the chief executive officer — and in time — the world would be a different place.  

At Tata Sons, N Chandrasekaran was at the helm for over nine years. Going by Tata Group’s policy, he had two more years to go for his retirement. Yet, according to media reports, all board members except Noel Tata favoured another term of five years for him.  

At HDFC Bank, Sashidhar Jagdishan, who had served as managing director for over five years, declared just a few months ago that he was raring to go for another term. Clearly, he had the backing of the board then. Things changed dramatically after Rajiv Kumar took over as the bank’s chairman.  Mr Jagdishan announced last month that he would not offer himself for reappointment.

One is not getting into the merits of what transpired. The point here is that boards seem congenitally incapable of telling an incumbent that it’s time for them to move on. 

At Tata Sons, it was left to a scion of the house of Tata to overrule the other directors. At HDFC Bank, it required a former IAS officer and Constitutional authority to take a position very different from that of the board until then. Board members, other than the promoter, seem incapable of asserting themselves in such a fashion — not just in India but the world over. 

As a result, professionally managed boards seldom ask an incumbent to leave. The incumbents carry on until they reach their age limit or term limit — or until disaster strikes. Succession planning at most boards is a farce. The only succession planning that happens is done by the CEO — and it is all about ensuring that no successor emerges. 

Boards fail at succession planning for the same reason that they are largely dysfunctional and ineffectual: They lack the ability to seriously question and challenge the CEO (or executive chairman). The result is underperformance at several places — often hidden while the incumbent is around — and disaster at some, after a star CEO leaves. 

One notable disaster was the failure of the Royal Bank of Scotland in 2008, the biggest in the history of banking. The 17-member board did not have it in itself to challenge the decision of the CEO, then a celebrated figure, to go in for the acquisition of ABN Amro. The decision led inexorably to the implosion of the bank. After the Global Financial Crisis of 2007, it turned out that the story was not very different at the boards of many of the biggest banks and investment banks in the world.

One of the best diagnoses of the underlying problems of governance came, not from a panel of finance or management experts, but from the UK Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards  , mostly comprising career politicians. The bane of most boards, the Committee noted, was that there was too much “collegiality” on the board. One veteran corporate executive caught the spirit of boards beautifully in his testimony to the Committee:

You have dinner with people the night before and one of them says, “Do you want to borrow my house in Tuscany and the rest of it?” It doesn’t happen to me, but you know what it mean(s). Then the next day at the board meeting, do you say to them, “Look, I have three questions for you and I’m not going to stop until you've answered all three of them properly”? People don’t do that.

How true! It’s awkward to pose tough questions to  management. Nobody likes to strike a jarring note in the proceedings. And that has partly to do with how board members are selected.

The non-executive chairman has a key role in selecting board members. Behind the scenes, the CEO has an important input in the selection of board members and a key role in the selection of the chairman himself. The individuals the chairman and the CEO select for the board are those with whom they have been on back-slapping terms at the clubs where they hang around. 

Board members are well remunerated — the median pay at the top 50 companies in India is ~70 lakh. To challenge the CEO is to risk non-renewal of one’s term and possible ostracism from boards in general.  

The UK Parliamentary Commission proposed some remedies. One was that the Nominations and Remuneration Committee or NRC be chaired by a senior independent director, not the chairman. Another was advertising independent director positions so that a wide enough pool was available. Neither proposal has taken off because it’s not clear how they improve matters.

If we want directors to exercise their independence, we need to tackle the problem of self-selecting boards, of which the CEO is a member and influencer. The process at public-sector enterprises in India is instructive. The concerned ministry appoints independent directors through the Bureau of Public Enterprises and without reference to the chairman/CEO. Independent directors are not beholden to management for their appointment. Independent directors are required to submit a note annually to the BPE outlining key issues at the company on whose board they sit. 

This principle must be applied to the private sector as well. One way is to have at least some independent directors nominated by key stakeholders, such as institutional shareholders, institutional depositors, large lenders and retail shareholders. The NRC must not select all the independent directors. A less intrusive alternative is to have major stakeholders generate candidates for the NRC to choose from.  Involving multiple stakeholders in board selection is the key to creating true diversity and independence in the boardroom.

Board membership must be seen as serious work, not as providing opportunities for a lunch outing. The UK Parliamentary Commission referred to the fact that independent directors at banks are required to devote 30-36 days in a year to their boards. The chairman’s position, it said, must be seen virtually as a full-time one. The chairman of a large bank “should usually not hold any other large commercial non-executive, let alone executive, positions.”

These proposals are not the end of the matter. But they are a good starting point. We need radical reform in the boardroom, not the tinkering that has failed to alter the reality of zombie boards. 

 

















Chairman's exit at Coforge Ltd is truly extraordinary

Some months ago, the world was shocked when the Chairman of HDFC Bank chose to resign from the board on what he regarded as point of principle.

What has happened at Coforge Ltd (formerly NIIT) is quite extraordinary. It is the company -or the board- that has caused the resignation of the Chairman, OP Bhatt, on a point of principle.

It appears that Mr Bhatt resigned following an internal audit of the board evaluation process. Boards are required to conduct an annual evaluation of board members. This typically involves an outside agency seeking the view of board members on their peers and producing a rating. The ratings and the general assessment of the agency are presented, first, to the NRC of the board and then the whole board.

The internal audit showed that only Mr Bhatt and the Chairman of the NRC had access to the full rating report. In  making a presentation to the board, they concealed material facts, including the fact that Mr Bhatt had received the lowest rating.

Now, getting the lowest rating in itself is not a big problem. If the others get a score of 8 and the Chairman gets, say, 6 or 7, it doesn't look good but boards can live with it. Even if the Chairman's rating is much lower than that of the others, it's a problem only if it persists year after yar.

There are two facts that should make people sit up. One, that an internal audit of the board evaluation process was conducted at all. Such an audit is unusual or even unknown. Did the internal audit team propose it ? Or was it commissioned by the Audit Committee of the board? Why was it undertaken in the first place? Was there an apprehension that  all was not well with the board evaluation findings?

Secondly, the fact that Mr Bhatt's peers on the board apparently gave him a lower rating than they gave others. Typically, the Chairman gets high ratings and even  the highest from other board members. Board members are keen to have their terms renewed and would not like to give a low rating to the Chairman. The ratings are supposed to be confidential but everybody knows that confidentiality can be easily breached in some matters.

Mr Bhatt was due to leave the board in any case end  April 2027 as he had failed secure the votes required for another term. The internal audit findings have merely hastened his departure.

In effect, a company Chairman has had to leave on a point of principle. And the rest of the board has been instrumental in bringing about this outcome. Two cheers for the triumph of corporate governance!


Tuesday, June 30, 2026

President can fire anybody at 'independent' agencies but the Fed is different: US Supreme Court

The US Supreme Court ruled that those in leadership positions at various independent agencies including the Federal Trade Commission serve at the pleasure of the US President. The President can, therefore, remove them at will.

Not so the members of the Board of Governors of the US Federal Reserve. They can be removed only for "cause" meaning the President must prove that they have done something that deserves removal. The court did not define what "cause" meant but indicated the threshold would have to pretty high. 

Why the different treatment?

Well, the Supreme Court contends that the many independent agencies are all part of the executive- they exist to enforce various statutes. As a result, they come under the authority of the President. And the President has the right to decide who he wants to work with. Period.

As for the Fed, it has been historically conceived as an agency that is independent of the executive. Without such independence, it cannot execute its mandate effectively. 

President Trump had fired Governor Lisa Cook on charges of  mortgage fraud. The US Supreme Court is saying those charges have to be proved and Cook must have the right to defend herself before she can  be removed.

In short, there is only one truly independent agency and that is the US Federal Reserve. The Fed is not an extended arm of the Treasury. All the other agencies cannot claim such independence. 


Friday, June 26, 2026

How open is the Strait of Hormuz?

We know one thing for sure about the MoU that the US and Iran have signed.

The US wants the Strait of Hormuz opened as quickly and fully as possible. If that happens, oil prices keep falling for a while and governments get a chance to replenish their strategic reserves. To keep oil flowing at the maximum rate in the 60 day negotiation period is what the US wants. 

At the end of 60 days, there is room for an extension. The US administration will keep talking so that oil prices are under control in the run up to the mid-term elections to the US Congress in November. 

Iran would like oil to flow as slowly as possible. The greater the pain to the global economy, the greater is Iran's leverage. Moreover, within the 60 day period Iran cannot charge tolls or fees. After 60 days, it feels it has the right to charge fees towards services rendered to the ships.

So the incentives for both sides are clear enough.

What is not clear is how far the Strait has opened. The priority is to get the estimated 1000 ships stranded during the conflict out at the earliest. The sailors on these ships have had a terrible time in the past 100 days. The middle portion of the Strait needs to be demined and that will take time. Ships can pass through routes close to Oman or those close to Iran. 

The International Maritime Organisation (IMO) has created a route close to Oman through which, they say, tankers stranded during the conflict are passing at a furious pace. Iran objects, saying all ships must pass only through its own designated routes.

Just how much is going through?

In normal times, 135 ships transit the Strait each day. Military analyst Larry Johnson provides data to show that on June 23, only 7-13 ships transited the Strait. On June 24, according to FT, an estimated 41 ships transited, 15 via the Iran route and 26 via the Oman route. That is a huge jump. 

And that jump is precisely what provoked the Iran missile attack yesterday on a ship using the Oman route. The IMO has since suspended its evacuation plan. So the Strait appears to be closed again for practical purposes. 

In return for opening the Hormuz, Iran gets some of its assets released and it gets a waiver of oil sanctions for 60 days. But it loses it leverage over the global economy and the US economy.  

The ceasefire period thus seems to be working to the advantage of the US. The Oman route is spoiling the show for Iran. Iran cannot allow a situation in which it does not control the flow of traffic in the Strait of Hormuz. Hence the Iranian attack on a tanker in the Oman area.  

Will the US construe that as a violation of the MoU? And how will it react if it does?