FIIs have returned to India with a bang. Almost $9 bn dollar has flowed into the Indian equity markets until November 13.
Many ascribe this to the 'blue wave' in the US in the elections to Congress on November 3. They say that investors are switching out of AI stocks after the Democrats' win as they believe the Democrats will rein in things that conduce to AI investment such as data centres.
I am not sure. The FII inflows into India had resumed in the second week of October itself. Scepticism about AI stock valuations and a correction had started last summer with major cloud and AI hyperscalers falling 10 per cent in October. If investors had perceived Indian equities as the alternative, we would have seen large purchases of Indian stocks even earlier.
My own view is that confidence in a stable rupee is the more important factor. After the RBI curbs on forex demand in October, the rupee appreciated from just below 97 to the dollar to around 94. At that point, FIIs came to believe that they could expect better dollar returns from the Indian market than before and decided to plunge into Indian equities again.
The RBI's defence of the rupee- basically that is what it is even though the RBI calls it a reaction to excessive speculation- seems to have produced results for now.
More in my BS column, The real good news.
The real good news
It is the
stable rupee, not the blue wave in the US
Indians- and others in the United States (US) and elsewhere- jubilant over the blue wave that swept the Democrats to power in the US Congress, got a cold reality check last week. US President Donald Trump elevated one of his aides, Stephen Miller, as White House chief of staff.
Mr Miller
has been characterised as an anti-immigration hawk. He is better characterised
as an economic nationalist and a passionate advocate of Mr Trump’s “America
First” programme. Absolutely central to that programme is the use of tariffs to
advance America’s interests.
Mr Miller is
not the principal exponent of tariffs in the Trump administration.
Nevertheless, his elevation is important in that it signals that there will be
no retreat from Mr Trump’s ideological agenda. That means, among other things,
that the world cannot expect the slightest relief with respect to tariffs.
India must brace itself for more tough negotiations on the long-pending
India-US trade deal. There will be no respite with respect to H1-B visas
either.
The
seriously good news for India is not the blue wave but the turnaround on the
home front of a sort that few had expected. The rupee has appreciated
consequent to the forex measures the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) announced last
month. In October, it looked as though the rupee would slide below 97 to the
dollar in what looked like a free fall. Instead, the rupee has appreciated to
above 94.
The RBI’s
measures, which curbed the demand for dollars, are not the only reason for the
appreciation of the rupee. Global factors have contributed. Investors are
retreating from artificial-intelligence (AI) stocks. Yields on US Treasuries
have eased. The price of crude oil has dropped to below $100 per barrel.
But the
RBI’s measures are undoubtedly an important factor. By containing expectations
about rupee depreciation, they appear to have revived foreign institutional
investors’ (FIIs’) appetite for Indian stocks. Market pundits who claimed that
India had fallen off the radar of foreign investors may well end up looking
foolish.
The RBI’s
position is that it is not out to defend any particular level of the rupee. Its
measures in October were only about preventing “excessive” speculation.
“Excessive” speculation is hard to define or determine. The RBI governor said
that one-third of all foreign-exchange derivative trades were being cancelled
or closed out on the same day they were initiated. He also pointed to one-sided
bets against the rupee. It’s not clear why either should be regarded as
“excessive”. Both transactions could merely reflect expectations that the rupee
is likely to depreciate.
Speculation
is unhealthy when it threatens to destabilise the system, say, when large bets
are taken with little capital to support them, or when groups of participants
are colluding to push the exchange rate in a particular direction. A sudden
decline in the exchange rate is also unhealthy when it points to market
dysfunction, for example, when small transactions result in large movements in
the exchange rate.
There was no
evidence of any of these, yet the RBI thought it necessary to intervene in the
forex market. It did so for another compelling reason: Too steep a fall in the
exchange rate in a short period can be self-reinforcing and result in
overshooting.
When the
rupee depreciates by a large percentage over a certain period, investors such
as FIIs become jittery. They see that depreciation is eroding their dollar
returns. They head for the exit, which causes the rupee to depreciate even
further. By intervening to stabilise the rupee, the RBI can contain a perceived
currency risk. That improves the prospects of FIIs entering the market instead
of exiting, thereby causing the rupee to appreciate.
That is
exactly what seems to have happened after the RBI announced its curbs on dollar
demand in October. FII flows were hugely negative in April, May and June in the
current financial year. They turned
positive in July and August (apparently because of primary-market investment
while selling in secondary markets continued). FII flows turned negative again
in September and October.
The RBI
announced its curbs on the demand for dollars on October 10. By October 16, the
rupee had appreciated to 94.96 to the dollar from its level of 96.82 on October
8. At that point, FIIs turned net buyers and they remained net buyers for 14
sessions thereafter up to November 6. In the first six days of November, FII
inflows into equities were greater than the outflows in each of the months of
September and October.
When the RBI
announced its measures, critics said the curbs could not be sustained for
long. When the forex curbs are removed, the rupee will be under pressure
if oil prices rise above $100. They are right but it’s also true that sentiment
is a big factor in the markets. Intervention of the sort the RBI has undertaken
helps turn around sentiment in many ways.
First,
speculators betting against the rupee end up suffering losses when curbs on
dollar demand cause the rupee to appreciate. Such losses impair their capacity
to bet against the rupee once normalcy is restored. Secondly, the RBI has sent
out a signal that one-way bets can be costly. Market participants will think
twice before they bet against the rupee after the curbs are removed.
Thirdly,
market expectations of a steep depreciation in the rupee become less
entrenched. This encourages FIIs to invest in Indian equities. FII inflows, in
turn, contribute to further appreciation of the rupee. That is how the vicious
spiral of rupee depreciation in the previous months now promises to turn
virtuous.
When the RBI
announced its forex measures in October, critics refused to buy its position
that it was not defending any particular value of the rupee. They said
the RBI was doing precisely that. The talk in the market and in the media was
that an exchange rate of ~97 to the dollar was a line in the sand for the RBI.
Let us say
the market thinks the rupee should fall to 100 in three months. The RBI thinks
that should happen in one year and intervenes to prevent a sharp fall towards
100. Its intervention results in the rupee stabilising at 98. Is that a
defence of the rupee or preventing unhealthy speculation? Let the pundits and
market experts quibble. For now, the success of the RBI’s measures is cause for
celebration.
No comments:
Post a Comment